Bank Stock Investment Isn’t for the Weak-Hearted

Valuing Banks and Financial Institutions: Why Earnings Multiples Aren’t Enough

When it comes to valuing companies, earnings multiples such as the Price-to-Earnings (P/E) ratio are commonly used metrics. However, for banks and other financial institutions, these traditional valuation methods can be misleading. At Cutts & Co Accountancy, we understand the unique challenges and considerations involved in valuing these complex entities.

The Unique Nature of Banks

Banks and financial institutions generate revenue in ways that are distinct from non-financial companies. While non-financial companies primarily earn revenue through the sale of goods or services, banks derive a significant portion of their revenue from interest and investments. This includes interest rate spreads, where banks lend money at higher interest rates than they pay on deposits, and income from various financial services such as investment banking, asset management, and trading.

For instance, when you deposit money into your bank account, the bank uses this capital to issue loans to other customers at a higher interest rate. This difference in interest rates is a key source of revenue for banks. Additionally, banks earn fees from credit cards, investment banking services, and asset management, which further complicates their income statements.

Valuation Multiples for Financial Institutions

Given the unique revenue streams of banks, traditional valuation multiples like P/E and Price-to-Book Value (P/BV) may not capture the full picture. Here are some specific valuation multiples that are more relevant for different types of financial institutions:

– Banking – Commercial: EBITDA multiples can range from 12.1x to 17.5x depending on the revenue size of the institution.
– Insurance Companies: For commercial insurance, EBITDA multiples can range from 6x to 8.9x, while personal insurance companies see multiples from 5.2x to 8.5x.
– Lending and Payment Solutions: These sectors often see higher EBITDA multiples, ranging from 12.2x to 16.4x for lending and 12.3x to 16.4x for payment solutions.

The Role of Interest Rate Spreads

Interest rate spreads are crucial for banks, as they represent the difference between the interest earned on loans and the interest paid on deposits. This spread is a primary driver of a bank’s profitability. However, it is also subject to market conditions and regulatory changes, which can significantly impact the bank’s valuation.

Embedded Value in Insurance

For life insurance companies, the concept of Embedded Value is particularly important. This methodology involves projecting cash flows and profits over long periods, often 20 to 30 years, to capture the full value of the insurance policies. This approach is more complex than traditional earnings multiples and requires a deep understanding of actuarial science and long-term financial projections.

Cash Flow and Income Statements

The income statements of banks and insurance companies are structured differently from those of non-financial companies. They are typically divided into non-interest revenue and expenses, and interest revenue and expenses. This distinction is critical for accurate valuation, as it highlights the different sources of revenue and the associated costs.

For example, a bank’s income statement will include revenue from interest on loans, investment income, and non-interest income from fees and commissions. The cash flow statement, while similar to that of other companies, requires careful consideration of non-cash expenses and changes in current assets and liabilities.

Return on Equity (ROE) and Cost of Equity (Ke)

When valuing banks, it is essential to compare the Return on Equity (ROE) with the Cost of Equity (Ke). ROE measures the return a bank generates on its shareholders’ equity, while Ke represents the return investors expect to earn. If ROE equals Ke, the bank’s P/BV multiple should be around 1x, indicating that the bank is worth exactly its book value. This comparison helps in assessing whether the bank is generating returns that meet investor expectations.

Conclusion

Valuing banks and financial institutions is a complex task that requires a nuanced understanding of their unique revenue streams, cost structures, and market dynamics. While earnings multiples can provide some insights, they are insufficient on their own. By using EBITDA multiples, considering interest rate spreads, and analysing ROE and Ke, you can gain a more accurate and comprehensive view of these institutions’ value.

At Cutts & Co Accountancy, we specialise in providing tailored financial services that account for the specific needs and complexities of banks and financial institutions. Whether you are involved in mergers and acquisitions, financial modelling, or simply need to understand the valuation of your financial institution, our expertise can guide you through the process with precision and clarity.